RIBO Members Confirm Updated By-Law No. 3

What Ontario Brokers and Brokerages Need to Know

At the annual general meeting held on November 4, 2026, members of the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (“RIBO”) approved changes to its By-Laws, including changes to RIBO By-Law No. 3 (“By-Law 3”). By-Law 3 sets out the licensing and qualification requirements for individual brokers and brokerage firms. It also addresses continuing education, supervision and other ongoing licensing obligations. Please click here for a link to the new, amended By-Law 3.

We have prepared a summary, with applicable section references, of key changes to By-Law 3 that brokers and brokerages will want to review.

New Canadian Residency Requirement

By-Law 3 has introduced a new Canadian residency requirement for RIBO licensees. To become registered as an individual RIBO licensee, applicants must now reside in Canada and be Canadian citizens, permanent residents or otherwise legally authorized to work as insurance brokers in Canada. See Sections 3.2(a)(ii) and 3.2(a)(iii). Different requirements may apply to temporary licensees registered under Ontario’s labour mobility rules. See Section 5.1.

Existing brokers who live outside Canada have a five-year transition period to meet the new residency and work authorization requirements. That transition period ends on November 4, 2031. See Sections 5.2 and 9.1.

The changes to By-Law 3 include formal recognition of a six-month temporary licence for certain brokers who are licensed in another Canadian jurisdiction and apply under Ontario’s labour mobility rules.

Errors and Omissions Insurance

By-Law 3 includes more detailed requirements for errors and omissions (“E&O”) insurance and fidelity or crime coverage. Section 4.3 of By-Law 3 requires that, among other things, an active brokerage maintain E&O insurance of at least $3 million for each claim and $6 million in total coverage during the policy period. These limits must specifically be available for claims arising from activities regulated by RIBO in Ontario. Claims arising outside Ontario must not use up the limits reserved for Ontario claims.

Where one policy covers more than one licensee (which is defined in By-Law 3 as an individual member or a firm member), the policy must provide each licensee with at least $1 million for each claim and $2 million in total coverage after other limits or excess coverage available to the other insured firms have been exhausted. See Sections 4.3(c), 4.3(i) and 4.3(j).

Brokerages must provide RIBO, upon request, with current copies of E&O and fidelity policy documents. Copies must also be provided annually and at each policy renewal. RIBO expects that policies renewing on or after January 1, 2027 will include the updated requirements.

New Qualification for Appointment as Principal Broker

Section 6.1(a) of By-Law 3 sets out the conditions for the appointment of an individual as a Principal Broker. Section 6.1(a) now has a new requirement that an individual appointed as a Principal Broker must at all times have full and unrestricted access to every bank account maintained by or on behalf of the Firm Licensee, including every trust and operating account. This appears to be a substantive new obligation with potentially significant operational implications for firms.

Changes to Notification Requirements

The changes to By-Law 3 expand the events that a Principal Broker must report to RIBO. In particular, a Principal Broker must notify RIBO within ten (10) calendar days after becoming aware that certain insolvency or receivership proceedings involving the brokerage are being considered, are expected or have begun. This now specifically includes proceedings under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act and the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, as well as receiverships, reorganizations, windings-up and similar proceedings. See Section 2.7(b).

For the purposes of the notification requirements in Section 2.7(b) of By-Law 3, “material change” is now defined as any change, event or development relating to the business, operations, or financial condition of a Firm Licensee that would be reasonably expected to:

  • adversely affect the Firm Licensee’s ability to provide insurance-related services to the public;
  • result in the termination, suspension, material amendment, or non-renewal of one or more brokerage contracts with markets that the Firm Licensee represents;
  • compromise the protection of funds held in trust for insureds or insurers;
  • diminish the Firm Licensee’s compliance with the insurance coverage requirements set out in this By-Law, including Errors and Omissions and Fidelity insurance; or
  • otherwise be relevant to the Corporation’s assessment of the Firm Licensee’s ongoing suitability, supervision, or regulatory compliance.

Non-Active Firms Renamed Commissions Receipt Firms

Firms previously described as “Non-Active Firms” are now called “Commissions Receipt Firm Licensees.” These changes were made to clarify that the purpose of these entities is primarily to receive insurance commissions. An existing brokerage firm that is currently a “Non-Active Firm” must change its name by January 1, 2028 if the name could reasonably suggest that the firm is an active brokerage offering insurance services to the public. See Section 4.4.

The changes also formalize RIBO’s non-practising licence status. This allows an eligible person who is no longer working as an insurance broker to maintain their professional designation, provided the person clearly identifies themselves as non-practising. See By-Law 3, Sections 2.3, 3.1, 3.2(e), 5.1 and 8.1.

Effective Date and Transition Periods

By-Law 3 took effect on November 4, 2026, when it was confirmed by RIBO’s members. Brokers and brokerages generally need to comply with the updated By-Law now unless a specific transition period applies. See Sections 9.1 and 10.1 of By-Law 3.

  • Existing brokers who live outside Canada have until November 4, 2031 to meet the new Canadian residency and work authorization requirements.
  • A Commissions Receipt Firm Licensee whose name could reasonably suggest that it is an active brokerage offering insurance services to the public has until January 1, 2028 to change its name.
  • RIBO has indicated that errors and omissions insurance policies renewing on or after January 1, 2027 are expected to include the updated coverage requirements.

Moving Forward

Brokerages should review By-Law 3 now and determine whether they need to make any changes. In particular, brokerages should speak with their insurers or insurance advisors before their next E&O renewal and update their internal compliance procedures where needed. Early review will help avoid issues as the transition deadlines approach.

We would be pleased to discuss any of these changes. Please do not hesitate to contact us directly if you have any questions.

British Columbia’s New Restricted Insurance Agent Licensing Regime

Changes to Legislation and New Licensing Required for the Incidental Sale of Insurance

In December 2025, the BC government enacted amendments to the Financial Institutions Act, RSBC 1996, c 141 (the “Act”) and a new Restricted Insurance Agent Licence Regulation  (the “RIA Regulation”), which creates a licensing framework for certain businesses that sell insurance incidentally to their ordinary goods or services.

The amendments to the Act include the addition of a new section 174.1 that authorizes the issuance of a restricted insurance agent (“RIA”) licence to a prescribed list of persons who carry on a prescribed class of insurance business. The amendments to the Act and the RIA Regulation come into force effective January 1, 2027. Businesses currently selling insurance under the Insurance Exemption Regulation, B.C. Reg. 366/2007 (the “Exemption Regulation”), must apply for an RIA licence by March 31, 2027 to continue those sales.

The changes to the legislation and resulting licensing regime are intended to protect BC consumers. The RIA Regulation replaces several existing licensing exemptions and the restricted travel insurance framework with a formal RIA licence for prescribed non-insurance businesses.

Affected Businesses and Classes of Insurance

The RIA Regulation prescribes 18 classes of business that are subject to the RIA licensing requirements and, in table form, the classes of insurance each prescribed class of business may sell. Please see below for a copy of the table set out in section 4 of the RIA Regulation.

Item Column 1 Class of Persons Column 2 Classes of Insurance
1 Construction equipment dealerships Credit protection insurance

Construction equipment warranty insurance

Guaranteed asset protection insurance

2 Credit grantors Credit protection insurance
3 Customs brokers Cargo insurance
4 Deposit-taking institutions Credit protection insurance
5 Extraprovincial trust corporations Credit protection insurance
6 Farm implement dealerships Credit protection insurance

Farm implement warranty insurance

Guaranteed asset protection insurance

7 Freight-forwarding companies Cargo insurance
8 Funeral providers Funeral services insurance
9 Mortgage brokerages Credit protection insurance
10 Motor vehicle dealers Credit protection insurance

Guaranteed asset protection insurance

Vehicle warranty insurance

11 Peer-to-peer vehicle service providers Rented vehicle insurance
12 Pleasure craft dealerships Credit protection insurance

Guaranteed asset protection insurance

Pleasure craft warranty insurance

13 Portable electronics vendors Portable electronics insurance
14 Transportation companies Cargo insurance

Travel insurance

15 Travel agents Rented vehicle insurance

Travel insurance

16 Travel wholesalers Rented vehicle insurance

Travel insurance

17 Trust companies Credit protection insurance
18 Vehicle rental agencies Rented vehicle insurance

Once a prescribed business is licensed, the business, acting through its employees and agents in BC, may conduct insurance activities only for the classes of insurance specified in its licence. Individual representatives do not need separate insurance licences, but they must act through the licensed business and complete the required training.

BC and Other Provinces with Restricted Insurance Agent Licensing Regimes

BC joins Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and New Brunswick in regulating incidental insurance sales through restricted licensing regimes. However, the approaches differ, particularly on training and oversight. Alberta’s restricted licence categories have no prescribed education or experience requirements, while Saskatchewan, Manitoba and New Brunswick generally leave it to the restricted agent or sponsoring insurer to ensure representatives are properly trained. BC, on the other hand, is more prescriptive: representative training must be product-specific and accredited by the Insurance Council of British Columbia (the “Insurance Council”), accreditation is time-limited and must be renewed, and the designated representative must complete a separate Insurance Council course. Insurers and businesses with national programs should adapt their existing approach for BC, as a licence in one province does not authorize the same activity in another.

Regulatory and Licensing Requirements

Insurance products prescribed in the RIA Regulation must be optional and offered only incidentally to the licensee’s ordinary business. Prescribed businesses must comply with the following:

  • appoint a designated representative approved by the Insurance Council, who must be a sole proprietor, partner, director or officer of the business and must complete the Insurance Council’s designated representative course;
  • have written authorization from at least one insurer authorized in BC to write the relevant prescribed class of insurance, subject to a limited exception for certain manufacturer or retailer guaranteed warranties;
  • hold errors and omissions coverage of at least $1 million per claim and $2 million in the annual aggregate, and provide suitability information on their structure, ownership, management and legal, financial, licensing and disciplinary history; and
  • all selling representatives must complete accredited training before offering any of the prescribed insurance products, and consumers must receive required written disclosures, including that the insurance is optional and any cancellation rights.

Here is a link to the Insurance Council’s website and information about the designated representative course.  Here is a link to the Insurance Council’s page on training requirements for RIA representatives.

Term Licensing Where Accredited Training Is Not Yet Available

Recognizing that accredited training may not be available for every product at launch, the Insurance Council has advised (including in its November 3, 2026 webinar) that it may issue a short-term RIA licence to an applicant that:

  • applies before March 31, 2027;
  • otherwise meets the licensing requirements; and
  • confirms that its representatives have completed an existing, non-accredited training program covering the RIA performance requirements.

The Insurance Council is clear that this is not a waiver of training; it allows time for the existing program to be accredited. A term licence expires no later than May 31, 2028 and may be converted to a standard licence once accredited-training conditions are met.

Key Implementation Dates

Date Development
January 1, 2027 The new regime comes into force. New entrants must hold an RIA licence before beginning covered insurance activities.
January 4, 2027 The Insurance Council expects to open its online application process.
March 31, 2027 Key application deadline for eligible existing businesses seeking transitional protection and for applicants seeking the term-licence route.
December 31, 2027 Transition deadline stated by the Insurance Council for existing restricted travel insurance licence holders, subject to the detailed transitional rules.
May 31, 2028 Latest stated expiry date for qualifying term RIA licences.

 

The March 31, 2027 deadline does not necessarily end every existing exemption immediately. Under section 7 of the RIA Regulation, a qualifying exemption continues for a timely applicant until 30 days after the Insurance Council refuses the application or 90 days after it issues the licence. Separate transition rules apply to travel agents, travel wholesalers and existing restricted travel insurance licensees.

Insurers’ Responsibilities

Insurers underwriting affected products will play a key role in compliant distribution. They should identify distribution relationships with prescribed businesses, assess oversight, monitoring and record-keeping processes, and help coordinate the development and accreditation of product training. Not every agreement will require amendment, but contracts and procedures should be reviewed to confirm that responsibilities for licensing, training, disclosures, supervision and compliance are appropriately allocated.

Next Steps Prior to the Effective Date

In preparation for the January 1, 2027 effective date, affected businesses and insurers should review their insurance products against the prescribed classes of business and insurance and identify current arrangements that rely on licensing exemptions or restricted travel insurance licences. Businesses should also identify an individual to act as a designated representative, assess existing representative training, confirm insurer authorization and errors and omissions coverage, and update distribution contracts, consumer disclosures and compliance procedures to comply with the RIA Regulation.

Starting early will reduce the risk of interruptions to insurance distribution once the new regime takes effect.

Please contact us directly if you have any questions.

FSRA Signals That GAP “Products” Are Insurance — and Must Be Sold Through Licensed Channels

What is GAP? Guaranteed Asset Protection (“GAP”) coverage is optional protection sold to consumers who are financing or leasing a vehicle. GAP is designed to indemnify a consumer for the difference between a vehicle’s actual cash value and the outstanding balance on the consumer’s loan or lease if the vehicle is stolen or written off as a result of an accident.

A Warning from FSRA. On July 23, 2026, FSRA issued a consumer warning about the unlicensed sale of GAP coverage (the “Warning”). FSRA has identified GAP being sold by unlicensed dealers and individuals, sometimes under product wordings that name an insurer even though no licensed insurer issued the policy. FSRA cautions that affected consumers may have paid for coverage that is not valid and that these consumers risk having unpaid claims.

Why it matters. FSRA’s Warning is notable less for its consumer-protection message than for the clear and decisive position that FSRA has communicated. FSRA’s view is that these products may be presented in a way that deliberately implies they are not insurance to avoid the regulatory and legal requirements designed to protect consumers — for example, being described as a “loyalty program”. However, describing GAP insurance as a “loyalty program” does not change the fact that it is insurance, and as a result a license is required to sell GAP. In other words, FSRA is applying a substance-over-form approach: branding a product as a warranty, membership, or loyalty benefit will not remove it from the scope of insurance regulation. This is significant because Ontario, unlike several Western provinces, has no restricted or incidental-seller licensing regime tailored to GAP or similar ancillary automotive protection products. FSRA’s position is that GAP products can only be sold by licensed insurers, agents, or brokers.

Enforcement. It is not yet clear how FSRA will act on this position or whether formal enforcement will follow. However, FSRA stated it will continue to monitor the sale of GAP insurance and take appropriate action when it identifies violations of the Insurance Act (Ontario). FSRA has invited consumers who purchased GAP from an unlicensed business or individual to file a complaint.

Distinguishing Between Insurance and Debt Waivers. FSRA’s Warning did not discuss other types of products which are sometimes marketed as GAP coverage, but which are typically not regulated as insurance. These products are offered by companies that finance the purchase or lease of automobiles to consumers and provide that if the vehicle is stolen or written off as the result of an accident, the financing company will “waive” its right to collect any amount that remains owing on the vehicle which is in excess of the amount recovered through the consumer’s automobile insurance. These types of waivers are generally not considered insurance because they involve contractual obligations of the lender to waive future loan repayments, rather than an agreement to indemnify the consumer for a loss.

Practical Implication. Underwriting insurers should confirm that every GAP product bearing their name, which is not clearly a debt waiver product, was in fact issued by them as a policy of insurance rather than a service contract given FSRA’s concern that GAP products are being sold in circumstances where no licensed insurer stands behind the coverage. Insurers should also ensure their GAP products are accurately described as insurance and distributed only through licensed agents or brokers who are responsible for the sale. Dealers should verify there is a licensed insurer behind any GAP or “loyalty” product offered to consumers and that a licensed agent participates in each transaction unless the product is clearly a debt waiver and not an insurance product.

This alert is general information and not legal advice. Please contact us to discuss how these developments affect your specific programs.

 

Alberta Superintendent of Insurance Issues Updated Guidance on Motor Vehicle Warranties and Protection Products and What Constitutes “Insurance”

On December 19, 2024, the Alberta Superintendent of Insurance (the “Superintendent“) published a revised version of Interpretation Bulletin No. 05-2024, titled Motor vehicle warranty contracts, dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products (the “Revised Superintendent Bulletin“) originally published on October 18, 2024. In connection with the Revised Superintendent Bulletin, the Alberta Insurance Council (the “AIC“) also published information bulletin IB-2024-01 titled New Alberta Insurance Council (AIC) Restricted Business License insurance type – Motor vehicle warranty contract, dealership loyalty programs, and vehicle protection products (the “AIC Bulletin“).

The AIC Bulletin

This AIC Bulletin provides important licensing information, including application availability, related to a new restricted business license type required to sell dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products. It also provides further information about the requirement to hold a Restricted Certificate of Authority to sell certain motor vehicle warranty products that are now considered insurance products. It applies to all auto dealerships and equipment dealers selling motor vehicle warranty products, dealership loyalty programs, and ancillary motor vehicle protection products (e.g. key fob replacement coverage, glass protection products, non-manufacturer tire and rim warranties, etc.).

We describe the licensing requirements for each product as set out in the AIC Bulletin below.

The Revised Superintendent Bulletin

The Revised Superintendent Bulletin is consistent with the original Bulletin No. 05-2024 published in October 2024 which clarified the regulatory view of products commonly marketed by automobile dealerships in conjunction with the sale of motor vehicles. However, the Revised Superintendent Bulletin clarifies that any motor vehicle insurance product that is considered insurance must comply with all regulatory requirements applicable to the particular class of insurance, including having policy wordings approved by the Superintendent and rating programs approved by the Automobile Insurance Rate Board.

The Revised Superintendent Bulletin applies to three categories of products: (1) motor vehicle warranties, (2) motor vehicle dealership loyalty programs, and (3) motor vehicle protection products.

  1. Motor Vehicle Warranties

The Superintendent distinguishes between manufacturer warranties and third-party warranties. Warranties and extended warranties that are offered by the manufacturer (or a wholly-owned subsidiary) of the vehicle are not insurance and are instead subject to the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act (Alberta). However, the Superintendent states that if the coverage includes any risk, peril, damage or loss beyond those inherent deficiencies in the workmanship or materials arising from the production of the motor vehicle, such products are contracts of insurance.

On the other hand, where a motor vehicle warranty contract is issued by a person other than the motor vehicle manufacturer or its wholly-owned subsidiary (e.g., automotive dealer), these products are contracts of insurance. There is an exception for warranty contracts issued by a person providing coverage solely for those inherent deficiencies in the workmanship arising from the person’s service or repairs of a motor vehicle (e.g., automotive repairer), which are not considered insurance.

The Superintendent also confirms in the Bulletin that motor vehicle warranty insurance falls under the class “equipment warranty insurance” as defined in the Classes of Insurance Regulation, and is therefore included in the restricted insurance type “equipment warranty insurance” as defined by the Alberta Insurance Council in a 2020 publication, which is available here.

Licensing Requirement for Motor Vehicle Warranty Products

Pursuant to the AIC Bulletin, motor vehicle warranty contracts, including those issued by third parties, fall under the existing “equipment warranty insurance” type for restricted certificates of authority. Any business wishing to sell motor vehicle warranty contracts, including those from third parties, will be required to hold an “equipment warranty insurance” type of Restricted Certificate of Authority with AIC that authorizes the sale of those products.

  1. Motor Vehicle Dealership Loyalty Programs

The Superintendent describes dealership loyalty programs as products where the price is typically described as a membership fee, and a dealership discount is provided to consumers on a future replacement motor vehicle should an event occur that results in damage or total loss of the original motor vehicle. Discount values can vary and are based on several factors including, but not limited to, the type of loss, the sale price of the original motor vehicle, and motor vehicle age at the time of purchase. Such products indemnify consumers for part of the cost of purchasing a replacement motor vehicle only on the happening of a certain risk or peril, such as theft or collision. Accordingly, these loyalty programs are insurance and must be developed, sold, and underwritten in compliance with the Insurance Act (Alberta) (the “Act“). The Superintendent does not consider debt waivers (which are agreements by the lender of an auto loan to waive up to a certain amount of a vehicle loan if the vehicle is written off, and the insurance payment is less than the outstanding loan amount) to be insurance.

  1. Motor Vehicle Protection Products

The Revised Superintendent Bulleting sets out a non-exhaustive list of examples of vehicle protection products (defined as “VPPs“) that are considered insurance under the Act.

  • Deductible reimbursement and/or monetary credits given in the event of loss, damage, or theft of a motor vehicle;
  • Non-manufacturer tire and rim warranties providing for tire and rim replacement (warranties provided by the motor vehicle manufacturer for tires and rims included in the motor vehicle’s assembly are excluded and are not considered insurance).
  • Glass protection products promising to pay some or all of the cost of a windshield replacement;
  • Products intended to deter theft that include a promise to make a payment in the event of the theft and/or non-recovery of the motor vehicle (or part thereof), such as theft-deterrent etching or tagging and catalytic converter anti-theft devices, that include a promise to pay if the product fails;
  • Key fob replacement coverage; and
  • Payment for a motor vehicle rental provided in conjunction with a VPP that is insurance.

Roadside service plans, motor vehicle service plans that provide solely for planned maintenance or routine service of a motor vehicle, or minor repairs that are routine to the ownership of a motor vehicle, are not considered contracts of insurance.

The Superintendent further clarifies that whether a service plan contract is considered insurance or not will depend on whether the service relates directly to wear and tear due to the use of the item as opposed to damage from an external risk such as collision or theft. If the service/repair provided is for reasonable and expected wear and tear, it is likely not insurance.

The key distinction between whether a product is considered insurance or not is whether the product pays an amount or provides something of value in the event of loss or damage resulting from a fortuitous event, rather than a defect in the quality of the product or reasonable wear and tear.

Licensing Requirement for Dealership Loyalty Programs and VPPs

Auto dealerships and equipment dealers wishing to sell motor vehicle dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products must apply for and hold a “dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products” type of Restricted Certificate of Authority with AIC, which is a category of certificate that has been newly created. Loyalty programs and protection products must be underwritten by licensed insurers and dealerships and dealers who wish to sell these products must hold the new Restricted Certificate of Authority allowing the sale of motor vehicle dealership loyalty programs and ancillary motor vehicle protection products.

The AIC Bulletin states that the class of insurance for motor vehicle dealership loyalty programs and ancillary motor vehicle protection products depends on the type of product being sold and identifies the insurance classes of common dealership loyalty and ancillary motor vehicle protection products.

Applications for the new “dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products” type of Restricted Certificate of Authority were to be made available on AIC’s website from January 7, 2025.

Penalties

Failure to comply with the requirements of the Act in Alberta may result in an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 for each contravention. A person convicted under section 786 of the Act may also be subject to a fine of up to $200,000 (and if of a continuing nature, each day or part of a day constitutes a separate offence).

If you have questions regarding the Bulletin and its application to your business practices, you can reach out to a member of our team.

Motor Vehicle Dealerships in Ontario May Be Allowed to Sell Auto Insurance

On November 22, 2024, the Ontario Ministry of Finance (the “MOF“) proposed an amendment to O. Reg 704/21, Exemption Orders Under Section 15.1 of the Act, (the “Exemption Regulation“) that, if approved as proposed, would permit the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (“FSRA“) to exempt selected entities or persons from the prohibition under section 231 of the Insurance Act (Ontario) (the “Act“) as part of FSRA’s Test and Learn Environment (“TLE“).  A link to the proposal is here. The proposal is open for comment until January 6, 2025.

Section 231 of the Act currently prohibits motor vehicle dealers from engaging in activities relating to the sale of automobile insurance. If approved, the proposed amendment would allow automobile insurance products to be sold at motor vehicle dealerships through several different delivery mechanisms, including by brokers, agents, or direct writers present at the dealership. The proposed amendments may also allow for the implementation of an embedded insurance model where a consolidated price is offered for the vehicle and the insurance.

FSRA would oversee the implementation and administration of this regulatory change under FSRA’s TLE, in a relatively low-risk environment that would allow FSRA to gauge consumers’ and the market’s response to the change.

The proposal is open for comment and consultation until January 6, 2025. As part of the consultation process, the MOF and FSRA are asking for comments on the following questions:

  1. Would it add convenience and value for customers if motor vehicle manufacturers, dealers, or financing companies offer automobile insurance at the time of purchasing vehicles?
  2. How would the proposal to sell automobile insurance through motor vehicle manufacturers, financing companies, dealerships impact the automobile insurance and/or motor vehicle manufacturer/financing/dealerships market and consumers in Ontario?
  3. The government is seeking input on the following potential delivery methods that could be available to FSRA in the creation of this pilot project: (a) broker/agent led insurance, and (b) embedded insurance.
  4. Are there any other distribution models that MOF and FSRA should consider in the pilot?
  5. Are there any other general concerns about allowing motor vehicle manufacturers, financing companies, or dealerships to sell automobile insurance policies?
  6. Would you be supportive of the piloting of such initiatives?
  7. Any other additional comments that would help MOF and FSRA pilot such initiatives?

The MOF has stated that the proposed amendments are not likely to have any adverse regulatory impact. Comments and answers to the questions above may be submitted via email directly through the Ontario Regulatory Registry portal. See the link to the email portal for Proposal number 24-MOF025 here.

If you have questions regarding the proposed amendment and its application to your business practices, or if you would like assistance in preparing comments, please do not hesitate to reach out to a member of our team.

 

 

Alberta Superintendent of Insurance Issues Bulletin re Motor Vehicle Warranties and Protection Products

On October 18th, 2024, the Alberta Superintendent of Insurance (the “Superintendent“) published Interpretation Bulletin No. 05-2024, titled Motor vehicle warranty contracts, dealership loyalty programs and vehicle protection products (the “Bulletin“).

The Bulletin clarifies the Superintendent’s regulatory view of products commonly marketed by automobile dealerships in conjunction with the sale of motor vehicles. A link to the Bulletin is here – https://www.abcouncil.ab.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/tbf-superintendent-of-insurance-2024-05-bulletin.pdf.

We note that the Superintendent made an announcement on October 21, 2024 regarding a revised bulletin, which has not yet been published on its website.

This follows the issuance by the British Columbia Financial Service Authority of Regulatory Statement No. 24-008 Product Warranty, Vehicle Warranty and Automobile Insurance (the “BC Regulatory Statement“) on April 25, 2024, which advised that the BC regulator considers vehicle warranties to be insurance, and accordingly, they may only be sold by licensed agents (unless an appropriate exemption exists under BC legislation). Unlike Alberta, BC does not have a restricted licensing regime applicable to the sale of these products. A link to the BC Regulatory Statement is here.

The Bulletin applies to three categories of products: (1) motor vehicle warranties, (2) motor vehicle dealership loyalty programs, and (3) motor vehicle protection products.

  1. Motor Vehicle Warranties

The Superintendent distinguishes between manufacturer warranties and third-party warranties. Warranties and extended warranties that are offered by the manufacturer (or a wholly-owned subsidiary) of the vehicle are not insurance and are instead subject to the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act (Alberta). However, the Superintendent states that if the coverage includes any risk, peril, damage or loss beyond those inherent deficiencies in the workmanship or materials arising from the production of the motor vehicle, such products are contracts of insurance.

On the other hand, where a motor vehicle warranty contract is issued by a person (e.g., automotive dealer) other than the motor vehicle manufacturer or its wholly-owned subsidiary, these products are contracts of insurance. There is an exception for warranty contracts issued by a person (e.g., automotive repairer) providing coverage solely for those inherent deficiencies in the workmanship arising from the person’s service or repairs of a motor vehicle, which are not considered insurance.

The Superintendent also confirms in the Bulletin that motor vehicle warranty insurance falls under the class “equipment warranty insurance” as defined in the Classes of Insurance Regulation, and is therefore included in the restricted insurance type “equipment warranty insurance” as defined by the Alberta Insurance Council in this specification from 2020.

  1. Motor Vehicle Dealership Loyalty Programs

The Superintendent describes dealership warranty programs as products where the price is typically described as a membership fee, and a dealership discount is provided to consumers on a future replacement motor vehicle should an event occur that results in damage or total loss of the original motor vehicle. Discount values can vary and are based on several factors including, but not limited to, the type of loss, the sale price of the original motor vehicle, and motor vehicle age at the time of purchase. Such products indemnify consumers for part of the cost of purchasing a replacement motor vehicle only on the happening of a certain risk or peril, such as theft or collision. Accordingly, these loyalty programs are insurance, and must be developed, sold, and underwritten in compliance with the Insurance Act (Alberta) (the “Act“). The Superintendent does not consider debt waivers (which are agreements by the lender of an auto loan to waive up to a certain amount of a vehicle loan if the vehicle is written off, and the insurance payment is less than the outstanding loan amount) to be insurance.

  1. Motor Vehicle Protection Products

The Superintendent provides the following examples of vehicle protection products (which it defines as VPPs) that are considered insurance under the Act.

  • Deductible reimbursement and/or monetary credits given in the event of loss, damage, or theft of a motor vehicle;
  • Non-manufacturer tire and rim warranties providing for tire and rim replacement (warranties provided by the motor vehicle manufacturer for tires and rims included in the motor vehicle’s assembly are excluded and are not considered insurance).
  • Glass protection products promising to pay some or all of the cost of a windshield replacement;
  • Products intended to deter theft that include a promise to make a payment in the event of the theft and/or non-recovery of the motor vehicle (or part thereof), such as theft-deterrent etching or tagging and catalytic converter anti-theft devices, that include a promise to pay if the product fails;
  • Key fob replacement coverage; and
  • Payment for a motor vehicle rental provided in conjunction with a VPP that is insurance.

Roadside service plans, or motor vehicle service plans that provide solely for planned maintenance or routine service of a motor vehicle, or minor repairs that are routine to the ownership of a motor vehicle, are not contracts of insurance.

The Superintendent further clarifies that whether a service plan contract is considered insurance or not will depend on whether the service relates directly to wear and tear due to the use of the item as opposed to damage from an external risk such as collision or theft. If the service/repair provided is for reasonable and expected wear and tear, it is likely not insurance.

The key distinction between whether a product is considered insurance or not is whether the product pays an amount or provides something of value in the event of loss or damage resulting from a fortuitous event, rather than a defect in the quality of the product or reasonable wear and tear.

Penalties

Failure to comply with the requirements of the Act in Alberta may result in an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 for each contravention. A person convicted under section 786 of the Act may also be subject to a fine of up to $200,000 (and if of a continuing nature, each day or part of a day constitutes a separate offence).

If you have questions regarding the Bulletin and its application to your business practices, you can reach out to a member of our team.

 

RIBO Holds Town Hall re Mandatory Disclosures Guidance RIBO-002

The Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (“RIBO“) held a virtual town hall on Thursday, October 17 to clarify its expectations for disclosure set out in the new guidance Mandatory Disclosures Guidance RIBO-002 released in April 2024 (the “Guidance“), and to answer questions relating to the Guidance. A link to the Guidance is here.

Some key takeaways from the Guidance and the town hall are:

  • RIBO emphasized that mandatory disclosures must be made no later than at the time of the quote. This is a change from previous guidance which provided that disclosure must be at the point of sale.
  • Although Regulation 991: General requires disclosure in writing, verbal disclosure – if done correctly – can be more meaningful to consumers. If verbal disclosure is provided, the Guidance provides that brokers must follow up in writing to confirm the information that was disclosed.
  • A written follow-up can be made by sending PDF copies of the disclosures, or by including links to the documents in an email.
  • Any material change to compensation arrangements should be brought to consumers’ attention on an ongoing basis and at renewal. This can be done by sending links, provided that the broker highlights the relevant information in the email. A link by itself without any explanation or highlighting will be considered not sufficient by RIBO.
  • There is no requirement to obtain written confirmation from the client that they have received the disclosure. However, obtaining written confirmation may make sense and work within a broker’s internal processes and workflows.
  • The commission disclosure requirements apply to commissions received from MGAs as well as from insurers. Brokers must disclose commissions received from all markets, not only insurers. The presenters invited brokers to contact RIBO if they would like to see MGA specific disclosure guidance.

RIBO began enforcing the disclosure and record-keeping requirements set out in the Guidance as of October 1, 2024. Compliance will be enforced by RIBO through its spot-check program and by investigations. RIBO advised that records of disclosure that are difficult to locate or understand, or disclosure that is unclear or vague, will be treated as “non-compliant”.

A recording of the presentation and a copy of the slide deck will be posted on the RIBO site in the coming weeks.

If you have questions regarding the Guidance and its application to your business practices, you can reach out to a member of our team.

Alberta Reduces Regulatory Charges for Unlicensed Insurance

On May 31, 2022, the Alberta government passed Bill 16: Insurance Amendment Act, 2022.  Among other things, the amendments under this Act:

  • reduce the current regulatory charge for purchasing unlicensed insurance from 50% of the premium payable for unlicensed insurance to 10%;
  • reduce the 50% financial penalty for the late payment of all charges and tax on unlicensed insurance, to 10%; and
  • more closely align the Alberta Insurance Act with other Canadian jurisdictions.

The Superintendent of Insurance in Alberta has also recently issued an Interpretation Bulletin 07-2022 on unlicensed insurance in Alberta, which replaces Interpretation Bulletin 02-2017 and provides updated clarification on the requirements for disclosure of unlicensed insurance in accordance with the new amendments to the Alberta Insurance Act.

FSRA’s New Supervisory Framework for Life and Health Agents Means More Proactive Supervision

New Supervisory Framework

On March 29, 2022, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (“FSRA“) announced the launch of the first Life and Health Agent Supervisory Framework (the “Framework“). The Framework represents FSRA’s new, proactive approach to supervising the sale of life and health insurance and is the first ever supervision framework for life and health agents in Ontario. Click here for the full text of the Framework.

Before the launch of the Framework, FSRA and its predecessor’s approach to the supervision of life agents was reactive. Supervision and enforcement focused mainly on those agents who self-declared non-compliance or were in response to complaints against specific agents[1]. Now, FSRA has established a dedicated Life and Health Insurance Agent Unit (the “LAU“) which helped develop the Framework and, going forward, will be responsible for implementing and scaling the Framework, setting target examination volumes and integrating industry best practices into the Framework.

Has anything changed?

The regulatory requirements applicable to insurers and agents remain the same and the Framework does not change any of the legal or licensing requirements applicable to life and health agents under the Insurance Act (Ontario) (the “Act“), Regulation 347/04 (the “Regulation“), or the CCIR and CISRO’s Conduct of Insurance Business and Fair Treatment of Customers Guidance (the “FTC Guidance“). Nor does the Framework alter the insurer’s ultimate responsibility for oversight of agent conduct. The legislation and FSRA still require insurance companies “to ensure that agents comply with the Insurance Act, the regulations and agent licensing requirements” and that insurers “must complete due diligence when delegating functions to managing general agents, such as agent screening and oversight”[2]. What has changed is that FSRA is now taking a proactive approach to supervising and enforcing compliance with these requirements and has dedicated more resources to the supervision of the sale of life and health insurance.

Four Components of the Framework

The Framework sets out the processes and key supervisory components that FSRA will use and consists of the following four key components:

  1. Life agent risk profiling
  2. Life agent examinations
  3. Communications and enforcement actions
  4. Reporting

 

  1. Life Agent Risk Profiling

The agent profiling process will focus on agents with the highest risks. Higher risk agents will be identified using FSRA’s internal data captured through licensing applications, licensing renewals, consumer complaints, the submission of the Life Agent Reporting Form (“LARF“) by insurers, and life agent enforcement activity reported by other regulatory bodies across Canada[3].

  1. Life Agent Examinations

Once a life agent has been identified with a higher risk profile and is referred to LAU through agent licensing management or consumer complaints management, LAU will then begin an ad hoc examination of the identified agent. During the pilot, FSRA developed a six-step examination process which consisted of (i) notice of examination and questionnaire, (ii) review and assessment of questionnaire including confirmation of compliance processes for FINTRAC and applicable privacy and data security legislation, (iii) requesting client files, (iv) file review, (v) agent interview, and (vi) a report on the findings and escalation for review if appropriate.

Based on the results of the pilot, FSRA determined that these steps were an effective method for determining compliance. Please see Appendix A of the Framework for a detailed description of the ad hoc examination process. This examination process will be used to test and verify the agent’s compliance with the Act, the regulations and FTC Guidance.

  1. Communications and Enforcement

The communications and enforcement component of the Framework means FSRA’s communication with the agent upon completion of the examination. The communication component will be performed by way of a closing letter confirming the outcome of the examination. This closing letter will confirm whether there were any contraventions of the Act, regulations or the FTC Guidance, or any other contraventions of business practices that are beyond FSRA’s jurisdiction. If the LAU concludes there were contraventions of the Act, the regulations or the FTC Guidance, the closing letter will also state whether the contraventions will be escalated to FSRA’s Legal and Enforcement Unit or a Regulatory Discipline Officer for enforcement action.

  1. Reporting

The reporting component includes the publication of reports and industry notices. Such reports and notices are intended to contribute to public confidence in FSRA and the life insurance industry generally by promoting transparency, disclosing information and deterring deceptive or fraudulent conduct by life agents.

During the pilot, FSRA published its Second Annual LARF Report dated May 10, 2021. In the Framework, FSRA discloses the outcomes of the pilot to the industry and the public. FSRA also published two industry notices which provided notice to the industry of the outcomes of examinations where FSRA identified potential consumer harm. In one case, an agent had altered clients’ work and study visas during the application process. These alterations were discovered by the insurer during the underwriting process and the agent was immediately terminated. In the second notice, the agent was found to have terminated insurance policies soon after receiving commission and the examination revealed that the agent had engaged in this same activity with other managing general agencies over several years, using the same pool of clients each time. Both industry notices confirmed insurers’ existing obligations under the Regulation to maintain a compliance system and report agents who are not suitable.

Although FSRA has become more proactive in its supervision of agents’ conduct of business, FSRA still expects insurers to oversee and monitor agent and managing general agency conduct. In both industry notices, FSRA reminded life and health insurance companies of their role in ensuring agents comply with legal obligations and meet high business conduct standards.

Conclusion

Based on the outcomes of its pilot project, FSRA has concluded that life agents in Ontario need to improve their overall business practices and that the insurers who are obligated to monitor the intermediaries authorized to sell their products need to review their life agent compliance programs. As FSRA implements and scales the Framework, FSRA intends to consult with the industry on integrating best practices enforcement into the Framework in support of the fair treatment of customers. FSRA also plans to consult with its stakeholders about what examination volume would be considered reasonable and proportionate within the Ontario marketplace.

[1] See pages 29 and 121 of the International Monetary Fund’s Country Report No. 14/72 – Canada Financial Sector Assessment Program ,dated March 2014.

[2] See FSRA Industry Notice titled FSRA Requires Insurers to Monitor Agent Conduct dated February 17, 2021, for more information.

[3] In 2009, FSRA’s predecessor, the Financial Services Commission of Ontario and Québec’s Autorité des marches financier implemented a common web based system to harmonize complaint data reporting requirements across Canada, except for British Columbia.

OSFI ISSUES FINAL REINSURANCE GUIDELINES

On February 11, 2022, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (“OSFI“) issued final versions of its revised Guideline B-3 Sound Reinsurance Practices and Procedures (“New Guideline B-3“) and Guideline B-2 Property and Casualty Large Exposures and Investment Concentration (“New Guideline B-2“) (together, New Guideline B-3 and New Guideline B-2 are the “New Guidelines“), marking the completion of Phase II of OSFI’s review of reinsurance practices which began with the publication of its Reinsurance Framework Discussion Paper in 2018 (the “Discussion Paper”).

The New Guidelines will not be effective until January 2025 and the current in-force guideline B-3 that was published in December 2010 (“In-force Guideline B-3”) will remain effective until that time. OSFI plans to hold information sessions in the coming months to help federally regulated insurers (“FRIs“) better understand OSFI’s expectations under the New Guidelines.

The remaining Phase of OSFI’s review of reinsurance contemplates possible changes to the MCT and LICAT capital guidelines, though no firm dates or timing for such changes have been released to date.

NEW GUIDELINE B-3

The “key principles” established under In-force Guideline B-3 which apply to all FRIs are substantially the same as those set out in New Guideline B-3 and the changes are primarily clarifications and amplifications of OSFI’s existing expectations. Having said that, FRIs will still need to begin adjusting current actuarial and compliance processes to meet OSFI’s expectations for stress testing, due diligence and monitoring of reinsurance counterparties under New Guideline B-3.

A summary of the key clarifications and changes in New Guideline B-3 is set out below.

Managing risks through reinsurance versus risks from the use of reinsurance

  • Although the first key principle in New Guideline B-3 is the same as in the In-force Guideline B-3, New Guideline B-3 distinguishes between OSFI’s expectations for managing risks through reinsurance and managing the risks arising from the use of The scope of an FRI’s reinsurance risk management policy (“RRMP“) should be expanded to include the risks that arise out of the use of reinsurance itself.
  • OSFI expressly acknowledges that reinsurance may be used for purposes not directly linked to mitigation of an FRI’s risks and that OSFI will review reinsurance arrangements based on the risk impact to the FRI.
  • Specifically, OSFI clarifies that, where risks insured in Canada are ceded by a foreign FRI back to the foreign FRI’s home office through affiliated reinsurers, OSFI will generally not recognize or grant credit for that foreign FRI’s reinsurance arrangements.

Stress Testing

  • Under the first key principle, both In-force Guideline B-3 and New Guideline B-3 state that an assessment of the adequacy and effectiveness of an FRI’s reinsurance arrangements may require stress testing of exceptional but plausible scenarios to determine if reinsurance arrangements adequately mitigate losses in accordance with the FRI’s risk appetite.
  • However, New Guideline B-3 provides more clarity and detail concerning OSFI’s expectations for stress testing and assessing reinsurance counterparty risk, as follows:
    • stress testing to assess counterparty risk should be considered at an aggregate level (e.g., group of affiliated counterparties);
    • counterparty risk should be assessed from the perspective of both going-concern and gone-concern scenarios of its reinsurers;
    • the process for assessing counterparty risk should be consistent regardless of whether counterparties are affiliated or non-affiliated;
    • the FRI should consider its total exposure to a counterparty as part of its assessment of counterparty risks;
    • an FRI should establish appropriate counterparty concentration limits applicable to both individual counterparties and to groups of affiliated counterparties; and
    • FRIs must maintain a record of the stress testing performed on its reinsurance program and provide copies to OSFI upon request.

Due Diligence

  • Under the second key principle in New Guideline B-3, OSFI’s expectations of an FRI’s due diligence on its reinsurance counterparties are substantially the same as under In-force Guideline B-3, with the added qualification that the level of due diligence should be “sufficient”.
  • In addition to the level of due diligence being commensurate with the FRI’s aggregate exposure to a reinsurance counterparty, OSFI has clarified that it now expects the level of due diligence with respect to a reinsurance counterparty should not be any less thorough if the counterparty is an affiliate of the FRI

New expectations for clauses in reinsurance contracts

In-force Guideline B-3 modifies the language of the insolvency clauses set out under the fourth key principle that OSFI expects to see in all reinsurance contracts. OSFI still expects that FRIs ensure all reinsurance contracts contain an insolvency clause which requires the reinsurer to continue to make full payments to the FRI without any reduction resulting solely from the FRI’s insolvency. However, New Guideline B-3 adds that, where the reinsurer is within the same corporate group as the ceding FRI, OSFI expects the reinsurance contract to contain a clause stipulating that “all reinsurance receivables are to be paid directly to the FRI-cedant in Canada, or to a person acting for, or on behalf of, the FRI-cedant in Canada”. The effect is that, where the reinsurer is an affiliate of the ceding FRI, this clause would apply whether or not the FRI-cedant is solvent or insolvent.

NEW GUIDELINE B-2

In the Discussion Paper, OSFI indicated that OSFI’s concerns with the current reinsurance framework were more prominent in the property and casualty (“P&C“) sector and that, as a result of its review of the existing reinsurance framework, there may be important changes to prudential limits and restrictions and capital adequacy for P&C FRIs.

New Guideline B-2, which applies to P&C FRIs on an individual and a consolidated basis, sets out OSFI’s expectations for P&C FRIs with respect to: (i) the losses they could withstand from a single large insurance exposure; (ii) the failure of an individual unregistered insurance counterparty; and (iii) investment concentration. Please see below for a high-level summary of OSFI’s expectations set out in New Guideline B-2.

Gross Underwriting Limit Policy

In addition to having an RRMP that meets OSFI’s expectations set out in New Guideline B-3, P&C FRIs are expected to have a Gross Underwriting Limit Policy (“GUWP“) which should:

  • define what constitutes a “Single Insurance Exposure[1]” for each class of insurance;
  • establish limits by class of insurance regarding the level of gross insurance risk that the P&C FRI is willing to accept in respect of a maximum loss related to a Single Insurance Exposure; and
  • be reviewed by senior management at least once a year.

OSFI expects that the determination of the acceptable maximum loss on a Single Insurance Exposure should be made without regard to the probability of the loss event using approaches that are risk-based and forward-looking, and not solely based on past losses.

In New Guideline B-2, OSFI expects P&C FRIs to consider the following in determining its Single Insurance Exposure for each class of insurance:

Property The aggregated insurance exposures on in-force policies at a single location, including any exposures subject to the location.
Credit The aggregated insurance exposures on in-force policies to any one single buyer or group of connected buyers.
Surety The aggregated insurance exposures on in-force bonds to any one single contractor or group of connected contractors.
Title The aggregated insurance exposures on in-force policies related to the legal title for a single location.

 

P&C FRIs will also be expected to provide OSFI, at OSFI’s request, with all information with respect to their large Single Insurance Exposures. OSFI may also, at its discretion, advise a P&C FRI to use specific criteria or an approach to determine and measure its maximum loss on a Single Insurance Exposure.

Insurance Exposure Limit

The New Guideline B-2 also sets insurance exposure limits that apply to the direct business written by P&C FRIs and the assumed business from any affiliated company where that affiliated company is a P&C FRI and is a direct writer of that business. A P&C FRI’s Net Retention[2] plus its Largest Net Counterparty Unregistered Reinsurance Exposure[3] should not, at any time, exceed the following limits for a maximum loss on a Single Insurance Exposure:

Insurance Companies 1)     100 percent of a P&C FRI’s Total Capital Available[4] where any entity in the P&C FRI’s control chain is:

a)     a widely held company; and/or

b)     a regulated financial institution; or

2)     25 percent of Total Capital Available otherwise.

 

Foreign Branches 100% of Net Assets Available[5].

 

OSFI expects that the Largest Net Counterparty Unregistered Reinsurance Exposure to a given counterparty, or group of affiliated counterparties, should be measured on a gross and a net basis (i.e., both before and after the recognition of any eligible counterparty risk mitigation (CRM) technique, including by means of the use of excess collateral or letters of credit[6]).

Investment Concentration

New Guideline B-2 provides that a P&C FRIs investment in any one entity or group of affiliated companies should not exceed the following limit:

Insurance Companies 5% of the company’s assets
Foreign Branches 5% of the company’s assets in Canada

 

For Foreign Branches, “assets in Canada” means the total value of assets under the control of the Minister of Finance (vested in trust in Canada), as reported on the balance sheet of the regulatory return filed with OSFI. These limits should also consider other investments or commitments not shown on the FRI’s balance sheet, such as options, futures, forward contracts and unfunded portions of committed loans.

OSFI’S NEXT STEPS 

OSFI still expects Boards of Directors of all FRIs to apply the New Guidelines within the context of their supervisory and oversight obligations set out in OSFI’s Corporate Governance Guideline and all FRIs will be staying tuned for the feedback that comes from industry information sessions in the coming months. The publication of the New Guidelines brings Phase II of OSFI’s review of reinsurance practices to a conclusion and we will be staying tuned for any changes to the MCT or LICAT guidelines as part of Phase III.

Footnotes

[1] In Annex 1 of New Guideline B-2, OSFI permits FRIs to define “Single Insurance Exposure” for themselves, stating that: “P&C FRIs can define what constitutes a Single Insurance Exposure within their GUWP.

[2] This term is defined in New Guideline B-2 as follows: “The amount of insurance exposure which a P&C FRI retains net for its own account and does not pass on to another insurer (or reinsurer). Any reinstatement premiums should be included in the Net Retention value.”

[3] This term is defined in the New Guideline B-2 as follows: “The largest amount of ceded unregistered reinsurance on an insurance exposure provided by a (re)insurance group (e.g., Affiliated Company counterparties that are part of a (re)insurance group). This amount should be on a net basis; that is, after recognition of any eligible CRM technique.”

[4] This term is defined in New Guideline B-2 as follows: “For a P&C FRI that is a company, the consolidated total available capital of a company as defined for the purpose of calculating the Minimum Capital Test (MCT) / Mortgage Insurer Capital Adequacy Test (MICAT).”

[5] This term is defined in New Guideline B-2 as follows: “For a P&C FRI that is a foreign branch, the net assets available as defined for the purposes of calculating the Branch Adequacy of Assets Test (BAAT).”

[6] New Guideline B-2 states that: “The limit on the use of letters of credit for unregistered reinsurance with a given counterparty, or group of Affiliated Company counterparties, including any letters of credit that are part of excess collateral, is 30% and is measured against the value of the insurance exposure.”

 

Contact Us