The Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (“RIBO”) recently published RIBO Guidance 007 – Referral Fee Guidance (the “Guidance”). The Guidance outlines RIBO’s expectations for individual and firm licensees that pay or accept referral fees and explains how referral fees differ from insurance commissions, marketing fees, lead-generation payments and gifts.
How RIBO Classifies Payments
The Guidance distinguishes among several types of payments that may arise and clarifies that it is the structure and purpose of a payment that determines its regulatory treatment, regardless of what the payment is called. The Guidance provides:
| Payment | RIBO Classification |
| Referral Fee | RIBO considers a one-time payment for referring a single consumer that is payable regardless of whether insurance is ultimately placed or the referral results in a successful transaction to be a referral fee (sometimes called a “finders fee”). |
| Insurance Commission | RIBO considers compensation tied to the number of policies sold, renewals, trailing or recurring payments, or premium volume to be an insurance commission. Insurance commissions may only be paid to licensed insurance brokers or agents. |
| Marketing Fee | RIBO considers compensation for general advertising, sponsorship, promotion or similar services intended to create broad awareness or direct consumers to a licensee to be a marketing fee. The payment cannot be connected to the successful placement, continuance or renewal of insurance. |
| Lead-Generation or Aggregator Payment | RIBO specifies that the treatment of lead-generation or aggregator payments depends on the activities performed and how the payment is calculated. Payments for connecting a specific consumer to a licensee must comply with the referral fee requirements. RIBO also considers providing personalized insurance quotes to be a regulated activity requiring an insurance agent or broker licence. |
| Gift | A one-time, non-contractual “thank you” gift of nominal value is not generally considered by RIBO to be a referral fee. Licensees must nevertheless avoid arrangements that could reasonably be viewed as referral fees, split commissions or incentives. |
What Qualifies as a Referral Fee?
RIBO considers a payment to be a referral fee where it meets all of the following criteria:
- it is a one-time payment, including monetary or non-monetary compensation, for the referral of a single consumer;
- the recipient recommended a potential client or business opportunity and is legally or contractually entitled to receive the payment; and
- the payment is made regardless of whether the business is bound or the referral results in a successful transaction.
A payment that that does not meet the above criteria is not considered a referral fee.
Who Can Pay or Receive Referral Fees?
RIBO licensees may only pay or receive referral fees to or from certain persons and businesses identified in section 15(1)(12) of Regulation 991 under the Registered Insurance Brokers Act. These include:
- licensed insurance brokers and agents;
- licensed mortgage brokers;
- licensed mutual fund representatives;
- licensed real estate brokers and agents;
- financial planners;
- premium financing businesses; and
- businesses providing products or services that reduce insurance risk.
For the “businesses providing products or services that reduce insurance risk” category, the product or service must be relevant to the consumer’s insurance policy and have a clear and demonstrable connection to reducing, preventing, mitigating or managing an insured risk. RIBO identifies home security companies, certain restoration and home improvement businesses, cybersecurity companies and plumbers providing risk-reduction services as possible examples.
Licensees must also be satisfied that an unlicensed referral partner did not engage in insurance brokering activities when making the referral. The Guideline states that from a consumer perspective, referrals are seen as personalized recommendations. Accordingly, licensees must only make a referral when it is in the consumers best interest and abide by sound business practices.
Consumer Consent and Disclosure
Licensees have consent and disclosure obligations under both the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Data Act and the RIBO Code of Conduct. Before sharing a consumer’s information through a referral arrangement, licensees must obtain and document the consumer’s written consent. RIBO has published a sample Client Consent for Name Referral form that licensees may adapt for this purpose.
Licensees must also disclose:
- any actual or perceived conflict of interest;
- any shared ownership, financial relationship or other connection between the parties;
- whether the referral may increase the consumer’s costs; and
- whether the licensee will pay or receive a referral fee.
Moving Forward
The Guidance demonstrates that the substance of an arrangement will determine its regulatory treatment. Brokerages should review their existing referral, marketing and lead-generation arrangements to:
- classify each arrangement based on the services performed and the structure of the compensation;
- confirm that each referral partner falls within a permitted category;
- ensure unlicensed referral partners are not providing insurance advice or engaging in other regulated activities;
- identify payments tied to sales, renewals or premium volume that may be treated as insurance commissions; and
- update consent, disclosure and record-keeping procedures where necessary.
We would be pleased to discuss the implications further. Please do not hesitate to contact us directly if you have any questions.


